Revenge: Biting the Dog That Just Bit You
I never heard of Austin O’Malley until I went searching for a good quote about revenge. According to the Irish leader (1760-1854), “Revenge is often like biting a dog because the dog bit you.” He must have learned the hard way that there is no joy or satisfaction in revenge.
People file lawsuits for different reasons. The one that worries me most in a potential client is revenge. In my experience, no lawsuit has ever satisfied a thirst for revenge.
Lawsuits accomplish good things when filed for the right reasons. When someone’s carelessness causes injury or death, what can we as a society do? No lawsuit can restore a person’s life or health, and while “an eye for an eye” sounds good, our courts are not in the business of putting people’s eyes out.
However, lawsuits provide compensation for “economic” losses (medical expenses and lost earnings), and “non-economic” losses (physical pain and suffering, mental anguish, physical impairment and disfigurement). Some think it wrong or impossibly difficult to translate pain or suffering into money damages. The truth is: no amount of money can make up for the loss of a mother or child, a lifetime of pain, or a disfiguring scar. But what else can we offer people? We must have a means of compensating you if your loved one, livelihood or health is wrongfully taken from you. Otherwise, your only recourse may be revenge.
Lawsuits also discourage bad behavior. The “litigation tax,” in plain terms, is the cost of preventing lawsuits by increasing safety. I don’t know about you, but I want the auto maker to think about the Ford Pinto exploding gas tank lawsuits when they decide where to position the gas tank on my car. When people and corporations are immune from lawsuits, they play fast and loose with safety. We have safer products, safer workplaces, and a safer society, due in large part to the work of lawyers.
Lawsuits prevent the need for revenge. When people have access to the courts, they have a means of righting the wrong visited upon them. It may be imperfect, but it is part of the fabric that holds our society together. Where people have no access to courts, they resort to guns. “Revenge killings” are rare in the US, but they are more prevalent in third world countries with no effective civil justice system.
“Living well is the best revenge.” I always liked that saying, although I never heard of George Herbert (English metaphysical poet, 1595-1633) until I Googled his quote. When lawsuits succeed, they compensate victims for their losses. For someone who has lost what money can never replace, the ability to live well (or at least better) is the best we as civilized people can return to them.



